🥊 My Rivian R1T vs my Lightning comparison review

MNLightning · Jun 10, 2022

These are just my "Opinions"

Kind of like trying to pick which kid you like more. Both have their Pro's and Con's
Ride - Lighting. Actually it's not that close from a comfort basis
Ride - R1T. Actually it's not that close from a Sporty/Handling basis/feel
Interior - Lightning. I just like the APPLE CAR Play and XM Radio, Seats, Cup Holders, Fold Down Spot for My Laptop and more. For me the R1T might be more contemporary but it's less usable for my purposes.
Exterior - R1T. Looks more futuristic
Size - Personal preference.... I'd tip toward the R1T as for trailering or as someone said a "Snowplow" I don't think either is a good choice for me. But for parking and maneuverability the R1T has the edge.
Frunk - Lightning. Mostly because of the lower threshold.
Power Supplies - Lightning both inside and outside the cab. 230v USB, charging etc...
Performance - R1T. Not even close. The Lighting is quick, but the RT1 is that and fast.
Off Road - R1T. Haven't done it and probably won't ever do what some here would consider a real off road work out.
Less Road Noise Wind Noise - Win - Lightning. By a fair margin, some of which might be because of the suspension on the Ford.
Which one to Keep----- I'll decide over the next week or so. I was offered $118,000 for the R1T and in spite of the plusses and minuses I'm not sure I want to part with it.

So depending on the daily use and your preferences either one can be a winner, but it doesn't make the other a loser.

Ford F-150 Lightning 🥊 My Rivian R1T vs my Lightning comparison review F150 Lightning vs Rivian R1T review comparison 4

Ford F-150 Lightning 🥊 My Rivian R1T vs my Lightning comparison review F150 Lightning vs Rivian R1T review comparison 1

Ford F-150 Lightning 🥊 My Rivian R1T vs my Lightning comparison review F150 Lightning vs Rivian R1T review comparison 2

Ford F-150 Lightning 🥊 My Rivian R1T vs my Lightning comparison review F150 Lightning vs Rivian R1T review comparison 3

Oneand0 · Jun 10, 2022

Congratulations twice!! Have a lot of fun trying to decide. Don’t forget serviceability!

Jerry The Cowboy · Jun 10, 2022

I am so stoked for you!
How amazing to walk out of your house and have to make that choice every day (or hour?? I would be looking for excuses to go somewhere!)
A big part of the joy is getting tired of one and then driving the other. But your description says you have many cars. Seven would be great, one for each day of the week.

monsterlag · Jun 10, 2022

That’s like $200k on the driveway there lol.

If you were to keep one, I would one 100% keep the Rivian. For the original price it was sold at, it’s a better deal than the Lightning Pro. They massively underpriced that truck.

Roy2001 · Jun 10, 2022

MNLightning said:
Ride - Lighting. Actually it's not that close from a comfort basis

Is that Lightning Star White?

Can you elaborate Lightning ride quality a bit?

MickeyAO · Jun 10, 2022

MNLightning said:
These are just my "Opinions"

Kind of like trying to pick which kid you like more. Both have their Pro's and Con's

Ride - Lighting. Actually it's not that close from a comfort basis

Ride - R1T. Actually it's not that close from a Sporty/Handling basis/feel

Interior - Lightning. I just like the APPLE CAR Play and XM Radio, Seats, Cup Holders, Fold Down Spot for My Laptop and more. For me the R1T might be more contemporary but it's less usable for my purposes.

Exterior - R1T. Looks more futuristic

Size - Personal preference.... I'd tip toward the R1T as for trailering or as someone said a "Snowplow" I don't think either is a good choice for me. But for parking and maneuverability the R1T has the edge.

Frunk - Lightning. Mostly because of the lower threshold.

Power Supplies - Lightning both inside and outside the cab. 230v USB, charging etc...

Performance - R1T. Not even close. The Lighting is quick, but the RT1 is that and fast.

Off Road - R1T. Haven't done it and probably won't ever do what some here would consider a real off road work out.

Less Road Noise Wind Noise - Win - Lightning. By a fair margin, some of which might be because of the suspension on the Ford.

Which one to Keep----- I'll decide over the next week or so. I was offered $118,000 for the R1T and in spite of the plusses and minuses I'm not sure I want to part with it.

So depending on the daily use and your preferences either one can be a winner, but it doesn't make the other a loser.

One question. Rivian has already had one recall...if they recall your vehicle for some reason, where does it go to have the fix action?

IdeaOfTheDayCom · Jun 10, 2022

MNLightning said:
These are just my "Opinions"

Kind of like trying to pick which kid you like more. Both have their Pro's and Con's

Ride - Lighting. Actually it's not that close from a comfort basis

Ride - R1T. Actually it's not that close from a Sporty/Handling basis/feel

Interior - Lightning. I just like the APPLE CAR Play and XM Radio, Seats, Cup Holders, Fold Down Spot for My Laptop and more. For me the R1T might be more contemporary but it's less usable for my purposes.

Exterior - R1T. Looks more futuristic

Size - Personal preference.... I'd tip toward the R1T as for trailering or as someone said a "Snowplow" I don't think either is a good choice for me. But for parking and maneuverability the R1T has the edge.

Frunk - Lightning. Mostly because of the lower threshold.

Power Supplies - Lightning both inside and outside the cab. 230v USB, charging etc...

Performance - R1T. Not even close. The Lighting is quick, but the RT1 is that and fast.

Off Road - R1T. Haven't done it and probably won't ever do what some here would consider a real off road work out.

Less Road Noise Wind Noise - Win - Lightning. By a fair margin, some of which might be because of the suspension on the Ford.

Which one to Keep----- I'll decide over the next week or so. I was offered $118,000 for the R1T and in spite of the plusses and minuses I'm not sure I want to part with it.

So depending on the daily use and your preferences either one can be a winner, but it doesn't make the other a loser.

You realize if you give up the Lightning... I'll be first in line asking for it.

As far as looks. I LOVE the fact that it's nearly identical to the ICE version. If it looked any different, it wouldn't be an F-150.

The only way I'll accept a futuristic F-150 is if the ICE version gets the same look.

Just a reminder, dibs on the Lightning if you decide on the RT1.

adoublee · Jun 10, 2022

The Rivian has a face only a mother could love. The Cybertruck, an entire body only a mother could love.

Roy2001 · Jun 10, 2022

adoublee said:
The Rivian has a face only a mother could love. The Cybertruck, an entire body only a mother could love.

It looks ugly to me.

Vorador · Jun 10, 2022

MNLightning said:
These are just my "Opinions"

Kind of like trying to pick which kid you like more. Both have their Pro's and Con's

Ride - Lighting. Actually it's not that close from a comfort basis

Ride - R1T. Actually it's not that close from a Sporty/Handling basis/feel

Interior - Lightning. I just like the APPLE CAR Play and XM Radio, Seats, Cup Holders, Fold Down Spot for My Laptop and more. For me the R1T might be more contemporary but it's less usable for my purposes.

Exterior - R1T. Looks more futuristic

Size - Personal preference.... I'd tip toward the R1T as for trailering or as someone said a "Snowplow" I don't think either is a good choice for me. But for parking and maneuverability the R1T has the edge.

Frunk - Lightning. Mostly because of the lower threshold.

Power Supplies - Lightning both inside and outside the cab. 230v USB, charging etc...

Performance - R1T. Not even close. The Lighting is quick, but the RT1 is that and fast.

Off Road - R1T. Haven't done it and probably won't ever do what some here would consider a real off road work out.

Less Road Noise Wind Noise - Win - Lightning. By a fair margin, some of which might be because of the suspension on the Ford.

Which one to Keep----- I'll decide over the next week or so. I was offered $118,000 for the R1T and in spite of the plusses and minuses I'm not sure I want to part with it.

So depending on the daily use and your preferences either one can be a winner, but it doesn't make the other a loser.

Did the dealership offer you 118k for the R1T or another party?

MNLightning · Jun 10, 2022

MickeyAO said:
One question. Rivian has already had one recall...if they recall your vehicle for some reason, where does it go to have the fix action?

Very local, within 10 miles

Ken · Jun 10, 2022

so the road noise is less in the lightning? That's nice. I did read they tried to soundproof it some. it can tell a huge difference on the highway between our Subaru Outback and the M-B GL350. The sound dampening in the GL is outstanding. How much do they two vehicles vary in overall length and width? It is noticeable parking, etc?

Yellow Buddy · Jun 11, 2022

What’s interesting is the

MNLightning said:
Kind of like trying to pick which kid you like more. Both have their Pro's and Con's

And as parents we also know that while you love all your kids equally…there’s one you definitely like more.

So which one is it?

Wolfpackfx4 · Jun 11, 2022

Sooooo…. How much you want for the Lightning….
And boy are you going to get a nice tax refund next year, hopefully some fun accessories.

nandyd · Jun 13, 2022

Reminds me of this:

Roy2001 said:
It looks ugly to me.

🥊 My Rivian R1T vs my Lightning comparison review

MNLightning

Member

Oneand0

Well-known member

Jerry The Cowboy

Well-known member

monsterlag

Well-known member

Roy2001

Well-known member

MickeyAO

Well-known member

IdeaOfTheDayCom

Well-known member

adoublee

Well-known member

Roy2001

Well-known member

Vorador

Well-known member

MNLightning

Member

Ken

Well-known member

Yellow Buddy

Well-known member

Wolfpackfx4

Member

nandyd

Member

Similar threads