VAF84
Well-known member
- Joined
- Oct 20, 2023
- Threads
- 22
- Messages
- 230
- Reaction score
- 201
- Location
- Central Texas
- Vehicles
- 2024 Sierra EV Denali
- Occupation
- Consultant
- Thread starter
- #1
Long read ahead; will be placed in both Lightning forums.
My buyback replacement truck has been built and getting shipped to the dealer. This means my EV days are numbered, unless I splurge on the GM EV trucks with the 440 range. Here are my final thoughts.
Albeit a roller coaster ride of emotions, the Lightning turned out to be an amazing truck in certain situations and at worst an inconvenient one in others. Iāve learned that anyone can make an EV work if they are determined, but those with bad use cases will have to change their lives to accommodate EV limitations.
Bar none my favorite part and biggest selling point was the driving experience; this and pricing lured me in. I will miss this the most, and itās really the biggest factor having me question going back to ICE. Closely followed by one-pedal driving, and then the frunk. If I ever pay a premium for an EV it will be for driving experience and range.
The single biggest improvement to my ownership experience came from access to the Tesla charging network. It was the game changer for my travels and ability to have peace of mind in EV deserts. I don't know if I'd own one without this access.
Iāve learned that geography has the single biggest impact on the EV experience. Having spent a lot of time in varied geographies and locations; I had times when I hated the truck, but others such as my current location where I finally experienced the highs and crazy numbers that frankly I was skeptical about when Iād read the comments.
The least pleasurable part of my experience was when working between KY and IN. Cold winters limited fast charging infrastructure, and lots of open highway was a range killer, and a lot of planning was involved. I had nowhere to plug in at night. Again, Tesla access began to change that for me, but I got access as I was leaving the area. Middle ground was in central Texas. Working from home, excellent of course. However, suburban sprawl, high speed limits, long open highways encouraging higher speeds reduced range which could be inconvenient at times. By far my best experience is currently in Louisiana. Warm weather, smaller city, low speed limits have led to me breaking 3mi/kw for the first time at 18k miles. Iāve even seen the number 4 briefly pop up!
Long trips. Trips with a radius of 350 miles had acceptable delays if charging infrastructure was good. I.e. at least one 150+ KW charger on the route and being able to charge at the destination. I had multiple 1,900mile round trips, and that was a headache. Yeah, I got it done, but 4 to 5 hours of added charging time each way to a 14-hour trip was honestly too much. Thank god for BC. Once the 440-range trucks proliferate and that charging time gets cut in half my last EV gripe will begone. Either that or sub 10min 10-80% fast charging time.
Mechanical Issues/Maintenance: I had a rocky start, but Ford ultimately addressed the issues. In my line of work, itās a big deal because I rely heavily on my vehicle. If I was always home, Iād been fine. Your local dealers will be the driving factor on what happens when things go wrong, but Ford corporate came through. Aside from the initial limp mode last December which was 1 week into my ownership, and coolant valve issue that ultimately got my buy back approved due to the amount of downtime, I really hadnāt seen anything else. Both of those happened at under 7k miles, Iām closing in at 19k miles as of now and will have 20k when it gets turned in this month. A few software glitches here and there that resolved themselves. I had a plastic piece pop out of the sunroof, minor but annoying (I swear itās always something with Ford panoramic). Iāve only rotated the tires aside from that.
EDIT 9/14/24: Two more issues popped up with days to go before my replacement. Before or around update 6.8.0 I got hit with a power reduction, felt like 50%. I drove hwy speeds for an hour with it, and it resolved itself during a pit stop. Second, the door keypad has decided to pop out. Must have broken tab, never had this happen before. Neither were addressed with service as I'm turning the truck in this week.
MAJOR NOTE: Donāt assume that the Ford dealer network means youāll have a better luck if things go wrong away from home. The dealer network influenced my decision to go with a Ford over a Tesla/ Rivian type. However, after shopping around, I wonder if my issues would have been resolved more quickly with a non-legacy EV retailer. Iām told by non-legacy they would have towed my car to wherever their shop is and got me a comparable rental. I feel that if you are in rural area and your local Ford dealer doesnāt have competent EV techs, then you may have longer downtime than at an EV focused repair shop. This is all anecdotal, but after this experience Iām less hesitant to buy a car without an extensive dealer network.
Towing: The topic has been beat to death; not going to get much into this. Around town itās good, but Iām not going to suffer through the experience of towing anywhere beyond that. All Iāll say is that IMO if your state doesnāt have a 55mph limit for towing and you value your time, donāt bother with anything over 120 miles radius. (Assumes bulky 8.5ā wide box shaped trailer of about 7k lbs)
Charging: Iāve charged off the following successfully: wall plug (about 1% an hr), 50amp house plug (6.5kwh), Tesla fast chargers (A2Z adapter), Tesla Mobile (primary charging device using Lectron adapter), diesel generators (38kw and I think 150kw, using generator adapter plug to 14-50, then plugged 50ā extension to Tesla mobile charger with Lectron adapter).
For me and my case; without range parity with an ICE; and by that, I mean 325 miles of unhindered, any weather, up to 80mph highway driving speeds, I would not pay equal to or more than the ICE equivalent. At most Iād pay 10% less. Having said that, unlike ICE your experience is exponentially affected by geography and living situation such as easy access to plugs. If youāre a commuter that takes few long trips, then maybe Iād pay same as ICE. I feel that most people with plug access will find EV ownership superior to ICE; this coming from a gear head that loves driving vehicles with overpowered ICE. Oh, and Iām in the oil and gas industry. I went from ambivalent to convert, if I can get the right product for my needs/wants at the right price. The Lightning came close, just needed more range to convince me to stick with it.
My buyback replacement truck has been built and getting shipped to the dealer. This means my EV days are numbered, unless I splurge on the GM EV trucks with the 440 range. Here are my final thoughts.
Albeit a roller coaster ride of emotions, the Lightning turned out to be an amazing truck in certain situations and at worst an inconvenient one in others. Iāve learned that anyone can make an EV work if they are determined, but those with bad use cases will have to change their lives to accommodate EV limitations.
Bar none my favorite part and biggest selling point was the driving experience; this and pricing lured me in. I will miss this the most, and itās really the biggest factor having me question going back to ICE. Closely followed by one-pedal driving, and then the frunk. If I ever pay a premium for an EV it will be for driving experience and range.
The single biggest improvement to my ownership experience came from access to the Tesla charging network. It was the game changer for my travels and ability to have peace of mind in EV deserts. I don't know if I'd own one without this access.
Iāve learned that geography has the single biggest impact on the EV experience. Having spent a lot of time in varied geographies and locations; I had times when I hated the truck, but others such as my current location where I finally experienced the highs and crazy numbers that frankly I was skeptical about when Iād read the comments.
The least pleasurable part of my experience was when working between KY and IN. Cold winters limited fast charging infrastructure, and lots of open highway was a range killer, and a lot of planning was involved. I had nowhere to plug in at night. Again, Tesla access began to change that for me, but I got access as I was leaving the area. Middle ground was in central Texas. Working from home, excellent of course. However, suburban sprawl, high speed limits, long open highways encouraging higher speeds reduced range which could be inconvenient at times. By far my best experience is currently in Louisiana. Warm weather, smaller city, low speed limits have led to me breaking 3mi/kw for the first time at 18k miles. Iāve even seen the number 4 briefly pop up!
Long trips. Trips with a radius of 350 miles had acceptable delays if charging infrastructure was good. I.e. at least one 150+ KW charger on the route and being able to charge at the destination. I had multiple 1,900mile round trips, and that was a headache. Yeah, I got it done, but 4 to 5 hours of added charging time each way to a 14-hour trip was honestly too much. Thank god for BC. Once the 440-range trucks proliferate and that charging time gets cut in half my last EV gripe will begone. Either that or sub 10min 10-80% fast charging time.
Mechanical Issues/Maintenance: I had a rocky start, but Ford ultimately addressed the issues. In my line of work, itās a big deal because I rely heavily on my vehicle. If I was always home, Iād been fine. Your local dealers will be the driving factor on what happens when things go wrong, but Ford corporate came through. Aside from the initial limp mode last December which was 1 week into my ownership, and coolant valve issue that ultimately got my buy back approved due to the amount of downtime, I really hadnāt seen anything else. Both of those happened at under 7k miles, Iām closing in at 19k miles as of now and will have 20k when it gets turned in this month. A few software glitches here and there that resolved themselves. I had a plastic piece pop out of the sunroof, minor but annoying (I swear itās always something with Ford panoramic). Iāve only rotated the tires aside from that.
EDIT 9/14/24: Two more issues popped up with days to go before my replacement. Before or around update 6.8.0 I got hit with a power reduction, felt like 50%. I drove hwy speeds for an hour with it, and it resolved itself during a pit stop. Second, the door keypad has decided to pop out. Must have broken tab, never had this happen before. Neither were addressed with service as I'm turning the truck in this week.
MAJOR NOTE: Donāt assume that the Ford dealer network means youāll have a better luck if things go wrong away from home. The dealer network influenced my decision to go with a Ford over a Tesla/ Rivian type. However, after shopping around, I wonder if my issues would have been resolved more quickly with a non-legacy EV retailer. Iām told by non-legacy they would have towed my car to wherever their shop is and got me a comparable rental. I feel that if you are in rural area and your local Ford dealer doesnāt have competent EV techs, then you may have longer downtime than at an EV focused repair shop. This is all anecdotal, but after this experience Iām less hesitant to buy a car without an extensive dealer network.
Towing: The topic has been beat to death; not going to get much into this. Around town itās good, but Iām not going to suffer through the experience of towing anywhere beyond that. All Iāll say is that IMO if your state doesnāt have a 55mph limit for towing and you value your time, donāt bother with anything over 120 miles radius. (Assumes bulky 8.5ā wide box shaped trailer of about 7k lbs)
Charging: Iāve charged off the following successfully: wall plug (about 1% an hr), 50amp house plug (6.5kwh), Tesla fast chargers (A2Z adapter), Tesla Mobile (primary charging device using Lectron adapter), diesel generators (38kw and I think 150kw, using generator adapter plug to 14-50, then plugged 50ā extension to Tesla mobile charger with Lectron adapter).
For me and my case; without range parity with an ICE; and by that, I mean 325 miles of unhindered, any weather, up to 80mph highway driving speeds, I would not pay equal to or more than the ICE equivalent. At most Iād pay 10% less. Having said that, unlike ICE your experience is exponentially affected by geography and living situation such as easy access to plugs. If youāre a commuter that takes few long trips, then maybe Iād pay same as ICE. I feel that most people with plug access will find EV ownership superior to ICE; this coming from a gear head that loves driving vehicles with overpowered ICE. Oh, and Iām in the oil and gas industry. I went from ambivalent to convert, if I can get the right product for my needs/wants at the right price. The Lightning came close, just needed more range to convince me to stick with it.
Sponsored
Last edited: