Sponsored

hturnerfamily

Well-known member
First Name
William
Joined
Jan 8, 2022
Threads
45
Messages
1,889
Reaction score
2,263
Location
rural Georgia
Vehicles
22 LIGHTNING PRO IcedBlueSilver 8/23/2022
Occupation
Owner
One of the MOST COMMON questions I got from the 'non-ev' crowd is:

"whach ya gonna do when you gotta replace that thar expensive Battery thang??"



oh well.
 

RickLightning

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 17, 2022
Threads
80
Messages
5,042
Reaction score
6,678
Location
SE MI
Vehicles
'22 Lightning ER Lariat,'22 Mach-E Premium 4X
One of the MOST COMMON questions I got from the 'non-ev' crowd is:

"whach ya gonna do when you gotta replace that thar expensive Battery thang??"



oh well.
Responses:

"Won't happen in my use of the vehicle".

"How about replacing the engine in your gas vehicle"?

"In 10+ years, for the tiny percentage that need it, cost will be lower".

Or, this response:

Ford F-150 Lightning EV Batteries Can Outlast A Vehicle’s Lifetime With Minimal Degradation, Study Finds blink
 

AZT9

Well-known member
First Name
Tom
Joined
Feb 6, 2022
Threads
19
Messages
503
Reaction score
843
Location
Peoria, AZ
Vehicles
2016 Escalade, 2018 Tesla Model 3
Gotta say, im happy with how the pack is performing. May not be 100% accurate but my
Scanner app says my overall SOH (state of health) is 96% on a 2022 with 63k miles and lots of DCFC sessions. Extrapolate that out and I’ll still be around 90% in the next 2-3 years. Not bad
 

Sponsored

Sedawk

Active member
Joined
Apr 3, 2024
Threads
0
Messages
37
Reaction score
65
Location
Canada
Vehicles
2023 XLT ER
While great, this is not news. The leading Li-Ion battery researcher Dr. Jeff Dahn from Dalhousie has been saying this for years because he has the data that proves it.
 
Last edited:

Jim Lewis

Well-known member
First Name
Jim
Joined
Jan 10, 2023
Threads
41
Messages
822
Reaction score
689
Location
San Antonio, TX
Vehicles
Honda Accord 2017; 2023 Lariat ER
Occupation
Retired
I thought the most telling part of the article was the chart towards the end on battery aging vs. climate:

The effects of temperature on EV batteries.
Another factor that can accelerate battery degradation is high ambient temperatures–to get around this, owners should try and park in the shade if possible. Furthermore, keeping the state of charge between 20% and 80% is ideal and will prolong the life of the pack compared to very high or very low states of charge.
 

invertedspear

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 18, 2023
Threads
17
Messages
1,157
Reaction score
1,606
Location
AZ, USA
Website
lightningcalcs.pages.dev
Vehicles
Antimatter Blue XLT (312A) ER, 2004 Jeep TJ
I thought the most telling part of the article was the chart towards the end on battery aging vs. climate:
Which is pretty in line with all the recommendations from @MickeyAO that so many people then shat upon with their "well the manual says this, and ..." insert personal anecdote about how they know better than people doing actual lab work on them. Those people will probably still call BS on this article.

You can lead a man to knowledge, but you can't make him think.
 

Maxx

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 15, 2021
Threads
39
Messages
1,901
Reaction score
2,202
Location
MD
Vehicles
23 Pro, Sky RL, Frontier, Aurora V8, Buicks, ....
"How about replacing the engine in your gas vehicle"?
I would love to see stats on that; ICE Engine vs EV motor failure or ICE gas tank vs EV battery pack failure.

Keep in mind, there is only one gas tank in every ICE but you can have 7000 batteries in one EV and a single battery failure could mean mean visiting the shop. My battery pack cost ( $28,556 ) is close to what I paid for my Pro ($40K - $7.5K) with each module costing $4K + Labor to replace along with not knowing if there are anything proprietary in the modules or BMS, it may be more of a crap shoot after year 8 than an ICE. Many of our battery operated devices are recycled after 8 years. My ICE truck was 20 years old with original engine and transmission with no repairs and running when I sold it. Manufacturers don't design these things for DYI repair. I am just saying I made a choice to buy this thing and I don't think people's fears are completely unfounded.
 
Last edited:

Sponsored

Mach Turtle

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 22, 2024
Threads
1
Messages
105
Reaction score
101
Location
Central California
Vehicles
2021 Mach E, 2024 XLT
Occupation
Bum
I would love to see stats on that; ICE Engine vs EV motor failure or ICE gas tank vs EV battery pack failure.

Keep in mind, there is only one gas tank in every ICE but you can have 7000 batteries in one EV and a single battery failure could mean mean visiting the shop. My battery pack cost ( $28,556 ) is close to what I paid for my Pro ($40K - $7.5K) with each module costing $4K + Labor to replace along with not knowing if there are anything proprietary in the modules or BMS, it may be more of a crap shoot after year 8 than an ICE. Many of our battery operated devices are recycled after 8 years. My ICE truck was 20 years old with original engine and transmission with no repairs and running when I sold it. Manufacturers don't design these things for DYI repair. I am just saying I made a choice to buy this thing and I don't think people's fears are completely unfounded.
Good points. For the closest thing we can get to an apples-to-apples comparison, we should compare a battery, a couple of motors, and electronics to...an engine, transmission, fuel system, emissions system with catalytic converter(s) and oxygen sensors and all that stuff, ICE electronics, and all the rest.

I agree that we have something to be concerned about. I'm betting that 8-10 years from now, the battery aftermarket and recycling economy will be at least somewhat up to speed, more similar to today's ICE aftermarket and repair, so EV repair and replacement prices will be more reasonable. Might win that bet or might lose it, but going to enjoy the ride.
 

Maxx

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 15, 2021
Threads
39
Messages
1,901
Reaction score
2,202
Location
MD
Vehicles
23 Pro, Sky RL, Frontier, Aurora V8, Buicks, ....
61k miles on a Platinum and FDRS says my battery health is 99%
Even if my battery health goes to 50%, it would not impact my daily use of the truck. Even for the weekend trips, with super chargers where they are, I will be fine. My only concern is battery failure. But as others have mentioned, I don’t let it mess up my enjoyment of the truck and recommending it to others. The way I see it, my ticker may fail before my battery does.
 

NCevGuyF150

Well-known member
First Name
John
Joined
Aug 10, 2024
Threads
0
Messages
50
Reaction score
16
Location
North Carolina
Vehicles
22 Ford lightning
Occupation
Repair technician
I would love to see stats on that; ICE Engine vs EV motor failure or ICE gas tank vs EV battery pack failure.

Keep in mind, there is only one gas tank in every ICE but you can have 7000 batteries in one EV and a single battery failure could mean mean visiting the shop. My battery pack cost ( $28,556 ) is close to what I paid for my Pro ($40K - $7.5K) with each module costing $4K + Labor to replace along with not knowing if there are anything proprietary in the modules or BMS, it may be more of a crap shoot after year 8 than an ICE. Many of our battery operated devices are recycled after 8 years. My ICE truck was 20 years old with original engine and transmission with no repairs and running when I sold it. Manufacturers don't design these things for DYI repair. I am just saying I made a choice to buy this thing and I don't think people's fears are completely unfounded.
Yes, I totally agree. As somebody who has recently had my 22 lariat in the shop with about 27,000 miles. They had to replace two battery modules. I understand that is the equivalent of 10 cells in each module. I was having lots of other issues, back up camera, collision avoidance, and some other features were corrupted and not working properly when the batteries failed. Thank God that Ford replaced this under warranty. They had my truck for 16 days. And after reading your post that says one module is $4000, there’s no way I can afford to have this truck if it begins to fail past warranty.
Sponsored

 
 





Top