• Welcome to F150Lightningforum.com everyone!

    If you're joining us from F150gen14.com, then you may already have an account here!

    If you were registered on F150gen14.com as of April 16, 2022 or earlier, then you can simply login here with the same username and password!

Sponsored

Messing with the Bull eventually gets you the horn... towed to charging station

jlferg0509

Well-known member
First Name
Jeff
Joined
Nov 16, 2022
Threads
7
Messages
88
Reaction score
127
Location
Dayton
Vehicles
2015 Chevrolet Malibu; 2023 Ford F-150 Lightning
So, after 17 months of use, more than 34k miles, multiple 2k mile trips, multiple trips towing my rv (over 7k lbs.), I finally found myself stranded with 1% energy...UUugh!

All that said, this was totally my fault. My wife and I were returning from our weekend rving trip, we'd stopped to charge at our last planned charging point about 40 miles out. Based on the trucks and my manual calculations I felt comfortable charging to 80% SOC giving us approximately 75 miles of range. My comfort level was based on averaging between 1.0 - .9 m/kh on the trip. The problem comes from the last hour of the trip. I noticed that we were burning through the SOC at an aggressive rate, we dropped down to .7 m/kh (I'd never seen this before, even during the winter) so I slowed down to 55-60 miles per hour, which did help a little on our burn rate a little.

We actually made it to our exit with approximately 8% SOC and I was faced with the decision, do I go left to a commercial charger less than a mile away or do I continue right to go to the storage location drop the trailer and limp home to charge. My hubris forced me to go right and a giant fail, even with the trucks warning multiple times that we had low range and outside the last charger range messages.

Needless to say that we ended up in front of our rv storage location at 1% SOC and the truck would not move. Frustrated with myself, I went into the Ford Pass App and submitted a request for assistance...very easy process. I was notified immediately that my request had been accepted and dispatched. The driver called me within 10 minutes to get an assessment of the situation and give me an approximate arrival time. He arrived in about 45 minutes, towed me to the EA charger about 3 miles away, I charged and was on the road again.

Lessons learned:
1) Pay attention to the truck (Trust the Truck @Ford Motor Company) messaging.
2) Looking back, during the excessive burn rate of .7 m/kw, I did notice that the battery external temperature had increased past the center point, almost between the center point and the next internal line. It would be great to actually see temperature values here... Additional information here, when this happened, we'd driven more than 100 miles in 90+ degree temperatures towing over 7k lbs.
3) Keep your ego in check, regardless of what you've learned or how many times you gone out see #1 lessons learned.
Sponsored

 

Grumpy2

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 23, 2022
Threads
15
Messages
552
Reaction score
535
Location
Central Oregon Coast
Vehicles
23 F150 Pro SR
Occupation
Retired Hvy Construction
Great write up and good advice, Thanks. The more I blunder through learning about the battery and BMS the more I understand how little I know about what is going on.
Remarkable response with the Ford Assist.
 

Ford Motor Company

Well-known member
Official Ford Account
First Name
Ford
Joined
May 26, 2021
Threads
17
Messages
1,457
Reaction score
882
Location
Dearborn
Vehicles
F-150
So, after 17 months of use, more than 34k miles, multiple 2k mile trips, multiple trips towing my rv (over 7k lbs.), I finally found myself stranded with 1% energy...UUugh!

All that said, this was totally my fault. My wife and I were returning from our weekend rving trip, we'd stopped to charge at our last planned charging point about 40 miles out. Based on the trucks and my manual calculations I felt comfortable charging to 80% SOC giving us approximately 75 miles of range. My comfort level was based on averaging between 1.0 - .9 m/kh on the trip. The problem comes from the last hour of the trip. I noticed that we were burning through the SOC at an aggressive rate, we dropped down to .7 m/kh (I'd never seen this before, even during the winter) so I slowed down to 55-60 miles per hour, which did help a little on our burn rate a little.

We actually made it to our exit with approximately 8% SOC and I was faced with the decision, do I go left to a commercial charger less than a mile away or do I continue right to go to the storage location drop the trailer and limp home to charge. My hubris forced me to go right and a giant fail, even with the trucks warning multiple times that we had low range and outside the last charger range messages.

Needless to say that we ended up in front of our rv storage location at 1% SOC and the truck would not move. Frustrated with myself, I went into the Ford Pass App and submitted a request for assistance...very easy process. I was notified immediately that my request had been accepted and dispatched. The driver called me within 10 minutes to get an assessment of the situation and give me an approximate arrival time. He arrived in about 45 minutes, towed me to the EA charger about 3 miles away, I charged and was on the road again.

Lessons learned:
1) Pay attention to the truck (Trust the Truck @Ford Motor Company) messaging.
2) Looking back, during the excessive burn rate of .7 m/kw, I did notice that the battery external temperature had increased past the center point, almost between the center point and the next internal line. It would be great to actually see temperature values here... Additional information here, when this happened, we'd driven more than 100 miles in 90+ degree temperatures towing over 7k lbs.
3) Keep your ego in check, regardless of what you've learned or how many times you gone out see #1 lessons learned.
Oh no! What a way to end a trip. We're happy to hear we could assist with getting you home. Thank you for sharing your experience.
 

RickLightning

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 17, 2022
Threads
76
Messages
4,724
Reaction score
6,154
Location
SE MI
Vehicles
'22 Lightning ER Lariat,'22 Mach-E Premium 4X
So, after 17 months of use, more than 34k miles, multiple 2k mile trips, multiple trips towing my rv (over 7k lbs.), I finally found myself stranded with 1% energy...UUugh!

All that said, this was totally my fault. My wife and I were returning from our weekend rving trip, we'd stopped to charge at our last planned charging point about 40 miles out. Based on the trucks and my manual calculations I felt comfortable charging to 80% SOC giving us approximately 75 miles of range. My comfort level was based on averaging between 1.0 - .9 m/kh on the trip. The problem comes from the last hour of the trip. I noticed that we were burning through the SOC at an aggressive rate, we dropped down to .7 m/kh (I'd never seen this before, even during the winter) so I slowed down to 55-60 miles per hour, which did help a little on our burn rate a little.

We actually made it to our exit with approximately 8% SOC and I was faced with the decision, do I go left to a commercial charger less than a mile away or do I continue right to go to the storage location drop the trailer and limp home to charge. My hubris forced me to go right and a giant fail, even with the trucks warning multiple times that we had low range and outside the last charger range messages.

Needless to say that we ended up in front of our rv storage location at 1% SOC and the truck would not move. Frustrated with myself, I went into the Ford Pass App and submitted a request for assistance...very easy process. I was notified immediately that my request had been accepted and dispatched. The driver called me within 10 minutes to get an assessment of the situation and give me an approximate arrival time. He arrived in about 45 minutes, towed me to the EA charger about 3 miles away, I charged and was on the road again.

Lessons learned:
1) Pay attention to the truck (Trust the Truck @Ford Motor Company) messaging.
2) Looking back, during the excessive burn rate of .7 m/kw, I did notice that the battery external temperature had increased past the center point, almost between the center point and the next internal line. It would be great to actually see temperature values here... Additional information here, when this happened, we'd driven more than 100 miles in 90+ degree temperatures towing over 7k lbs.
3) Keep your ego in check, regardless of what you've learned or how many times you gone out see #1 lessons learned.
Surprised at the response you got from the tow company, but that's great. Too many are posting "they had no idea", "they didn't have a flatbed", etc.
 

Tom Jensen

Well-known member
First Name
Tom
Joined
Jan 3, 2024
Threads
6
Messages
49
Reaction score
78
Location
Arlington, Virginia
Vehicles
F-150 Lightning 2023
Occupation
Attorney
So, after 17 months of use, more than 34k miles, multiple 2k mile trips, multiple trips towing my rv (over 7k lbs.), I finally found myself stranded with 1% energy...UUugh!

All that said, this was totally my fault. My wife and I were returning from our weekend rving trip, we'd stopped to charge at our last planned charging point about 40 miles out. Based on the trucks and my manual calculations I felt comfortable charging to 80% SOC giving us approximately 75 miles of range. My comfort level was based on averaging between 1.0 - .9 m/kh on the trip. The problem comes from the last hour of the trip. I noticed that we were burning through the SOC at an aggressive rate, we dropped down to .7 m/kh (I'd never seen this before, even during the winter) so I slowed down to 55-60 miles per hour, which did help a little on our burn rate a little.

We actually made it to our exit with approximately 8% SOC and I was faced with the decision, do I go left to a commercial charger less than a mile away or do I continue right to go to the storage location drop the trailer and limp home to charge. My hubris forced me to go right and a giant fail, even with the trucks warning multiple times that we had low range and outside the last charger range messages.

Needless to say that we ended up in front of our rv storage location at 1% SOC and the truck would not move. Frustrated with myself, I went into the Ford Pass App and submitted a request for assistance...very easy process. I was notified immediately that my request had been accepted and dispatched. The driver called me within 10 minutes to get an assessment of the situation and give me an approximate arrival time. He arrived in about 45 minutes, towed me to the EA charger about 3 miles away, I charged and was on the road again.

Lessons learned:
1) Pay attention to the truck (Trust the Truck @Ford Motor Company) messaging.
2) Looking back, during the excessive burn rate of .7 m/kw, I did notice that the battery external temperature had increased past the center point, almost between the center point and the next internal line. It would be great to actually see temperature values here... Additional information here, when this happened, we'd driven more than 100 miles in 90+ degree temperatures towing over 7k lbs.
3) Keep your ego in check, regardless of what you've learned or how many times you gone out see #1 lessons learned.
Life experience encourages humility.
 

Sponsored

TomB985

Well-known member
First Name
Tom
Joined
Jan 14, 2023
Threads
16
Messages
344
Reaction score
723
Location
Isanti, MN
Vehicles
2022 Lightning XLT ER
I wanted to say THANKS for sharing this. Your use is very similar to mine, and I can see the exact same thing happening to me.

I’ve pulled my camper over 7,000 miles in the 9 months I’ve had the truck, and I’ve gotten too comfortable pushing it down into the single digits. The added drag from the trailer makes efficiency much more dependent on wind conditions, so I probably shouldn’t keep thinking “it’ll be fine.” I returned last night at 6% from a 200-mile trip that needed a quick top-up at a Supercharger to make it home. I took 5% more than I did last week, and I’m glad I did.

Just for context, what size camper do you pull? I average 1.4 mi/kWh at 60-65 MPH with my Flagstaff A-frame.

Ford F-150 Lightning Messing with the Bull eventually gets you the horn... towed to charging station PXL_20240807_170427229_Original
 
OP
OP

jlferg0509

Well-known member
First Name
Jeff
Joined
Nov 16, 2022
Threads
7
Messages
88
Reaction score
127
Location
Dayton
Vehicles
2015 Chevrolet Malibu; 2023 Ford F-150 Lightning
I pull a Keystone Passport GT 2870, approximately 7,500 lbs loaded (for us). I usually average .9 -1.1 m/kw but this was an unusually hot day. I'll have to keep a closer eye on the battery temps in the future.
Ford F-150 Lightning Messing with the Bull eventually gets you the horn... towed to charging station 1000000140
 

TomB985

Well-known member
First Name
Tom
Joined
Jan 14, 2023
Threads
16
Messages
344
Reaction score
723
Location
Isanti, MN
Vehicles
2022 Lightning XLT ER
I pull a Keystone Passport GT 2870, approximately 7,500 lbs loaded (for us). I usually average .9 -1.1 m/kw but this was an unusually hot day. I'll have to keep a closer eye on the battery temps in the future.
That’s useful, thanks.

I monitor my info with an OBD reader, and I don’t think there’s any correlation between battery temp and efficiency. It’s all about wind, and I’ve seen a 70% swing between strong headwind and tailwind. Exactly the same with my gas burners towing a wind sail, but more of a big deal in the Lightning. There’s also an incentive to buy as little “gas” on the road as possible because of cheap home charging rates. That may get me stranded one day.
 

tls

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 29, 2022
Threads
16
Messages
362
Reaction score
317
Location
New York
Vehicles
2022 Lightning
2) Looking back, during the excessive burn rate of .7 m/kw, I did notice that the battery external temperature had increased past the center point, almost between the center point and the next internal line. It would be great to actually see temperature values here... Additional information here, when this happened, we'd driven more than 100 miles in 90+ degree temperatures towing over 7k lbs.
Sounds like you suspect the additional cooling demand from towing in high ambient temps had something to do with the decrease in efficiency and range? Makes sense to me.
 
OP
OP

jlferg0509

Well-known member
First Name
Jeff
Joined
Nov 16, 2022
Threads
7
Messages
88
Reaction score
127
Location
Dayton
Vehicles
2015 Chevrolet Malibu; 2023 Ford F-150 Lightning
Sounds like you suspect the additional cooling demand from towing in high ambient temps had something to do with the decrease in efficiency and range? Makes sense to me.
Yes, that was the only change from previous towing trips and that impact on my efficiency.

Again, I'd love to see the internal and external battery temperature values displayed beneath the display.
Sponsored

 
 





Top