Sponsored

Chinese EVs... may be better than we think

Danface

Well-known member
First Name
Dan
Joined
Sep 19, 2023
Threads
3
Messages
663
Reaction score
636
Location
Central Mass
Vehicles
2023 Lightning XLT
The best engines AMC had were the 327 (from Chevy) and the 390 (from Ford). Ugliest vehicle in US was a toss up between the Gremlin and the Pacer.
I liked Pacer. It was fun to drive. If the Pacer was the ugliest then looking at a Cybertruck should turn you to stone.
Sponsored

 

MM in SouthTX

Well-known member
Joined
May 22, 2022
Threads
17
Messages
454
Reaction score
498
Location
Texas
Vehicles
2022 Lightning Lariat ER
I think they started 16 years ago with the 2008 Beijing Olympics when the China air was so bad. In 2006 we read the "Inconvenient Truth", but generally ignored it.

Today they have terrific electric bullet trains, as well as high quality electric cars, as well as really cheap electric cars. We are trying to fence them out as we struggle to catch up.
Before we start lauding China as being ahead of us as a green nation...
 

mq019

Active member
First Name
Mark
Joined
Nov 25, 2023
Threads
4
Messages
38
Reaction score
30
Location
USA
Vehicles
2023 F150 Lightning Lariat ER
We can argue all day, both sides of whether or not they are more advanced and never settle the issue.

I have a few observations though (I'll try to keep the politics out of it, but it is inherently a political issue)....

1 - they may be superior at manufacturing batteries, but its not because we CANT do it here, but because we WONT do it here. Our EPA wont let us. Also, our government doesnt provide a large enough subsidy to make it worthwhile, and we pay folks in our manufacturing sector too much for it to ever be profitable. Tariffs (or I guess war) are the only possible response to a government that subsidizes an industry, and allows slave wages to a point that it has major negative national security and economic impacts on other countries.

2 - their "green" credentials are virtually non existent. They make a ton of EV's - doesnt make them "green". They are powering them with fossil fuels, and planning to burn more and more fossil fuels to generate the energy to manufacture and run those EV's. Also, they are essentially making disposable EV's from what I've seen - so cheap that its easier/cheaper to throw them away and get a new one when they get old/break. There are already stories of piles of NEW EV's sitting at ports that they cant move - just wait for the stories of piles of OLD EV's sitting around because it was more economical to replace them than fix them.

3 - Are their EV's really "better"? I have yet to see any safety or reliability studies on their vehicles. Maybe I've just missed them, but China doesnt have a great track record of building safe, reliable equipment. They still have yet to prove this. I'd love to see the NHTSA do reviews of some of these Chinese cars we keep hearing so much about. Reliability will be another thing that only time will tell. I've seen some nice looking electronics come from China that were absolutely worthless - software was terrible, components physically broke or failed after single or just a few uses, audio/video quality was terrible, etc etc. ad-nauseum. How will support be? Who's gonna fix that cheap EV when it has a problem? They have absolutely no infrastructure in place here to support their product, and we all know how great support will be if it involves calling China.

4 - Privacy - China is not known for their privacy. Aww hell, lets be real - there is no privacy. In a high tech vehicle with so so many cameras, mics, and other sensors, would you feel secure that your data isnt going to end up in the CCP massive database? That those cameras and mics wouldnt be abused? If you do, you're very very wrong. I have reservations about how much data our own automakers have or could have about us, what they do with it, and how they protect it. These Chinese companies are essentially owned by the CCP - I know exactly where it would end up, and it would absolutely be a national security threat. Think about China being able to, on demand, disable your EV if they dont like an American policy - you could become a tool of the CCP to put pressure on your own government so that you dont lose access to your vehicle. Nevermind the CCP having access to all of those cameras, mics, and gps logs - if you cant see the threat there, then 🤷‍♂️




And a thought - how about using their own system against them. IF they are really so much more advanced than we are, instead of tariffs, require that they build their vehicles and batteries here, in the US, and that they do it via partnerships with a local automaker and cant own more than 50% of the company. 🤔



Ok - I'm done - go ahead and crucify me! :crackup:
 

Sponsored

TaxmanHog

Moderator
Moderator
First Name
Noel
Joined
Jan 19, 2022
Threads
169
Messages
12,026
Reaction score
12,607
Location
SE. Mass.
Vehicles
2022 Lightning Lariat-ER Max Tow & 2024 Harley-Davidson Road Glide CVO-ST
Occupation
Retired
Exploded Mercedes EV had battery from China's Farasis Energy, gov't says

In an Aug. 5 update, Korea JoongAng Daily reported the electric vehicle contained batteries made by a Chinese firm.

They can keep that c graded garbage in asia.

 

DesertEV

Well-known member
First Name
Matthew
Joined
Mar 25, 2024
Threads
3
Messages
208
Reaction score
257
Location
El Paso, TX
Vehicles
Ford F-150 Lightning
Exploded Mercedes EV had battery from China's Farasis Energy, gov't says

In an Aug. 5 update, Korea JoongAng Daily reported the electric vehicle contained batteries made by a Chinese firm.

They can keep that c graded garbage in asia.

How prone are our Lightnings to catch fire like this from our battery?
 

TaxmanHog

Moderator
Moderator
First Name
Noel
Joined
Jan 19, 2022
Threads
169
Messages
12,026
Reaction score
12,607
Location
SE. Mass.
Vehicles
2022 Lightning Lariat-ER Max Tow & 2024 Harley-Davidson Road Glide CVO-ST
Occupation
Retired
How prone are our Lightnings to catch fire like this from our battery?
I'm only aware of the one truck that had an incident at the Rouge early 2023, so hopefully less likely.
 

Sponsored

3rdgenfan

Well-known member
First Name
Geoff
Joined
Oct 4, 2022
Threads
1
Messages
346
Reaction score
364
Location
Delaware
Vehicles
'23 XLT SR, G8 GXP, TDI Rabbit
100% tariffs were an interesting choice, but I feel the 'takeover' of lower priced, well made EVs should be a wake up call to the US manufacturers. We're constantly getting bombarded by $75k+ trucks or $150k+ cars and then when sales fall flat they call the whole thing off.

We need a new Bolt. I loved mine, it was cheap and went twice as far as the VW eGolf I was originally shopping. If they aren't going to make one here, then let us buy them from somewhere else.

Unfortunately the EV mindset for others will always be tarnished by the goal posts that move weekly regarding how far a car should go on one charge. Years ago it was "300 miles" now it's "650 miles and charge in 4 minutes"
 

Scorpio3d

Well-known member
First Name
Chris
Joined
Mar 18, 2024
Threads
16
Messages
504
Reaction score
556
Location
Texas
Vehicles
2023 Ford F150 Lightning Lariat ER
Occupation
SS/IBA car wash owner
4 - Privacy - China is not known for their privacy. Aww hell, lets be real - there is no privacy. In a high tech vehicle with so so many cameras, mics, and other sensors, would you feel secure that your data isnt going to end up in the CCP massive database? That those cameras and mics wouldnt be abused? If you do, you're very very wrong. I have reservations about how much data our own automakers have or could have about us, what they do with it, and how they protect it. These Chinese companies are essentially owned by the CCP - I know exactly where it would end up, and it would absolutely be a national security threat. Think about China being able to, on demand, disable your EV if they dont like an American policy - you could become a tool of the CCP to put pressure on your own government so that you dont lose access to your vehicle. Nevermind the CCP having access to all of those cameras, mics, and gps logs - if you cant see the threat there, then 🤷‍♂️




And a thought - how about using their own system against them. IF they are really so much more advanced than we are, instead of tariffs, require that they build their vehicles and batteries here, in the US, and that they do it via partnerships with a local automaker and cant own more than 50% of the company. 🤔



Ok - I'm done - go ahead and crucify me! :crackup:
Speaking of data privacy!

https://www.cnn.com/2024/08/13/busi...s-driver-data?cid=external-feeds_iluminar_msn
 

Warren

Active member
First Name
Warren
Joined
Nov 5, 2023
Threads
1
Messages
39
Reaction score
22
Location
Ohio
Vehicles
F150 Lightning Pro
Occupation
Carpenter
How prone are our Lightnings to catch fire like this from our battery?
So tired of this myth. The latest research shows that electric cars are 10 to 20 times LESS LIKELY to catch fire than an ICE car.
Sponsored

 
 





Top