Sponsored

The Least Reliable Cars, Trucks And SUVs You Can Buy In 2025, According To Consumer Reports

StevenC56

Well-known member
First Name
Steven
Joined
Sep 13, 2024
Threads
4
Messages
299
Reaction score
264
Location
Fresno California
Vehicles
2024 Lightning Lariat Avalanche, 2017 Explorer Platinum
Occupation
Retired
First I've ever heard of Jalopnik. That being said I don't get out much. But if I do, I'm driving my 2024 Lightning Lariat or my wife's 2017 Explorer Platinum.
 

RickKeen

Well-known member
First Name
Rick
Joined
Sep 14, 2022
Threads
45
Messages
568
Reaction score
738
Location
Minnesota
Vehicles
F150L SR Pro
Occupation
sw engineering manager,
At least the Lightning had a good overall score.
 

MotoGary

Well-known member
First Name
Gary
Joined
Jun 30, 2021
Threads
0
Messages
63
Reaction score
213
Location
Utah
Vehicles
'23 Lightning XLT 12/23 Build Date, '22 Mach-E (traded)
Looks like I made the right choice buying the Lightning over the GMC Canyon.
 

Sponsored

subseavet

Active member
First Name
Chris
Joined
Dec 19, 2023
Threads
1
Messages
39
Reaction score
60
Location
Herndon, VA
Vehicles
2023 Ford F150 Lightning Lariat Extended Range
Occupation
R&D Engineer
https://jalopnik.com/the-least-reliable-cars-trucks-and-suvs-you-can-buy-in-1851714745

don't shoot the messenger.. I absolutely love my "23 Lariat. best vehicle I've ever owned.
Same here (Also a '23 Lariat). Virtually all of the "problems" I've had I've been able to solve via this forum or simple fixes on my end. Most have been discovering the differences between how various things are implemented differently in an F150 EV vs. an ICE F150. Consumers are much less willing to solve problems independently than they have been in the past and much quicker to report being annoyed by things that do not require dealer intervention to solve. As a result, you get poor reliability scores; if you follow this forum and others like it closely, you know that while there are problems, most are relatively minor and straightforward to address, and the others, Ford seems to be pretty well on top of. Heck, @Ford Motor Company monitors this forum and helps customers out all the time! Because EVs are still new across the board for all big automakers, it will take time for dealerships to develop the skills and get the equipment needed to work on EVs, but that change is happening. I wish it was going much faster and dealers were better, but here we are. I love my '23 Lariat Lightning and am already considering ditching my other ICE vehicle for another EV.
 

TaxmanHog

Moderator
Moderator
First Name
Noel
Joined
Jan 19, 2022
Threads
180
Messages
13,447
Reaction score
14,438
Location
SE. Mass.
Vehicles
2022 Lightning Lariat-ER & 2024 HD Road Glide CVO-ST
Occupation
Retired
How the heck did they arrive at a 28/100 score!?!?!?

I'm very happy with my '22 Lariat-ER, no major powertrain failures, admitting the annoyances with software functionality and untimely updates, it's still a reliable EV truck in my humble opinion.
 

Mach Turtle

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 22, 2024
Threads
1
Messages
134
Reaction score
134
Location
Central California
Vehicles
2021 Mach E, 2024 XLT
Occupation
Bum
Just had a look at the actual CR ratings on the real CR site. The Lightning is the highest rated electric truck (of both of them! Only Lightning and R1T have finished testing so far). Its predicted reliability rating is somewhat below average but not in the basement. They're testing a Silver and a Musk Ox, so hopefully we'll see how those compare soon.

The details of the reliability score suggest to me that they have a really small sample size; high and low ratings are all over the place. For example, the "EV Charging" reliability rating went from highest in `22 to lowest in `23. Is the charging system completely different? Not likely. More likely that no `22 owners reported charging problems to CR, then one or two `23 owners reported that they had problems, and with few reports, the percentage of problems jumped to a level considered problematic.

The text of their reviews is pretty positive IMHO; I read it before deciding to buy a Lightning as part of over-researching the field and it didn't put me off at all.

I think CR is useful but to be taken with a grain of salt, while certain clickbait sites that quote CR out of context are best ignored.
 

rparry

Active member
First Name
Bob
Joined
Nov 20, 2024
Threads
2
Messages
26
Reaction score
26
Vehicles
F150 Lightning Flash Ordered Nov. 18th 2024
Occupation
Retired
I have not trusted CR for many years. I agree with Mach Turtle that their data sets must be very small. I have seen wild fluctuations in reliability from one MY to the next when nothing has changed. For years they could not understand why anyone would want to drive anything but the least expensive Civic made. TRUCKS OMG!
 

Sponsored

scoobybri

Well-known member
First Name
Brian
Joined
Apr 19, 2024
Threads
8
Messages
85
Reaction score
225
Location
Virginia, USA
Vehicles
2023 Lightning XLT w/Max Tow and TT Packs
Let's see...my 23 Lightning had to have the shifter replaced within 6 months. My 2021 Model Y left me stranded twice due to a manufacturing issue with the battery connector. My 2017 Chevy Bolt had to have the entire motor pulled to fix an issue with the steering column...in the first 3 months of ownership. I've owned lots of new cars since I bought my first new vehicle in 1990 (a base as base can be Ford Ranger) and of all vehicles, the EVs have had the most issues the soonest into ownership. I think that this is due to the rush that manufacturers had to push new EV models to the market. Growing pains as they say. I would still take the early adopter road all over again if I had the choice. Not burning dino juice and the almost complete lack of maintenance more than makes up for the occasional problems I have had
 
Last edited:

Whammy Bar

Well-known member
Joined
May 30, 2022
Threads
23
Messages
589
Reaction score
912
Location
SoCal
Vehicles
Reliable - 1971 F100; Unreliable - 2022⚡Lariat ER
Occupation
Electrician
Man, the F150 Hybrid got 7/100.

Nice that they have 2 products on the same platform on the list for consistency.
 

Henry Ford

Well-known member
First Name
John
Joined
Dec 21, 2022
Threads
7
Messages
1,152
Reaction score
1,614
Location
Michigan
Vehicles
2022 F150 Lightning Platinum
I personally don't trust CR anymore. I have seen top much obviously cherry picked data, or skewed article in search of a predetermined conclusion. JMHO
I think Consumer Reports is reliable but their priorities and mine don't always line up. For instance, energy use us weighted the same as washing, drying, and noise for dishwashers. Energy use is nice but it's well down the list of things I care about and should be weighted less.

I find CR useful if you dig a bit deeper into the ratings. CR lists don't tell the whole story, which is unfortunate because click factories like Jalopnik publish the lists without context.
 

queuewho

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 27, 2022
Threads
4
Messages
534
Reaction score
592
Location
Western PA
Vehicles
22 F150 Lightning Lariat SR
Let's see...my 23 Lightning had to have the shifter replaced within 6 months. My 2021 Model Y left me stranded twice due to a manufacturing issue with the battery connector. My 2017 Chevy Bolt had to have the entire motor pulled to fix an issue with the steering column...in the first 3 months of ownership. I've owned lots of new cars since I bought my first new vehicle in 1990 (a base as base can be Ford Ranger) and of all vehicles, the EVs have had the most issues the soonest into ownership. I think that this is due to the rush that manufacturers had to push new EV models to the market. Growing pains as they say. I would still take the early adopter road all over again if I had the choice. Not burning dino juice and the almost complete lack of maintenance more than makes up for the occasional problems I have had
Yeah I had a model 3 for 4 years and the trunk filled with water due to the seal failing, a short in the rear motor killed the 12v repeatedly and had to be taken in twice before they figured it out, required a motor swap. The tires started cupping, they never solved that one. The onboard charger had modules fail, so I was stuck at 16 amps until that was fixed.

After 2 year mark, warranty work on the truck so far... rear lightbar replacement for the recall.
Sponsored

 
 





Top