Sponsored

Why isn’t the Lightning getting more of the gas F150 market?

Calvin H-C

Well-known member
First Name
Calvin
Joined
Dec 15, 2022
Threads
4
Messages
252
Reaction score
211
Location
Richmond Hill, Ontario, Canada
Vehicles
Ford Focus Electric 2017, F150 Lightning Lariat
Occupation
Technical Trainer/Writer - Wayside Railway Signalling Maintenance
...at a minimum it usually devolves to questioning one’s sexuality
Of course it does, but is should involve stating the need to have a vehicle that makes noise to compensate for a certain body part being small. 😉
Sponsored

 

21st Century Truck

Well-known member
First Name
Martin
Joined
Jul 11, 2024
Threads
7
Messages
340
Reaction score
356
Location
Virginia
Vehicles
Ford 150 Lightning 2023 XLT ER pkg. 312A
So you take multiple long road trips..

I guess it could work if you don't mind stopping every couple hours. Which I did on our long road trip. One thing I was missing was the Tesla adapter. the nearest regular charging station at our destination was 30 minutes away.
Of course I don't mind stopping every couple of hours. Neither does the dog. Neither do the kids.

I agree the Tesla adapter did make it a bit easier, except for West Virginia.
 

Scorpio3d

Well-known member
First Name
Chris
Joined
Mar 18, 2024
Threads
20
Messages
695
Reaction score
761
Location
Texas
Vehicles
2023 Ford F150 Lightning Lariat ER
Occupation
SS/IBA car wash owner
My calculations show that for a similarly-equipped F-150 ICE Lariat, purchasing a Lightning over the ICE will pay me back within 2-3 years. Maybe even sooner since my assumption was 10,000-14,000 miles per year and I'm on track to put 15,000 to 20,000 miles a year.
When I did the calculations of a similarly priced four-wheel-drive lariat with the eco-boost engine versus the lariat lightning, I was already $1000+ ahead, including the $7500 tax incentive only! Add in the savings of go go juice and that should be at a minimum $1000 per year at 10,000 to 12,000 miles.
I was lucky and purchased mine at the right time and my savings on the initial purchase were substantially higher and I installed solar so my savings for go go juice cost is also substantially higher.
 
Last edited:

SpaceEVDriver

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 9, 2022
Threads
17
Messages
337
Reaction score
567
Location
Arizona
Vehicles
2023 Lightning Lariat ER, 2022 Mustang Mach-E
When I did the calculations of a similarly priced four-wheel-drive lariat with the eco-boost engine versus the lariat lightning, I was already $1000+ ahead, including the $7500 tax incentive only! Add in the savings of go go juice and that should be at a minimum $1000 per year at 10,000 to 12,000 miles.
I was lucky and purchased mine at the right time and my savings on the initial purchase were substantially higher and I installed solar so my savings for go go juice cost is also substantially higher.
I wrote some software (well, spreadsheet functions) that model everything from the future cost of energy for the vehicle to the cost of maintenance to depreciation (first year and subsequent years), insurance, etc., etc., etc. I typically run 10,000 to 1 million simulations on each vehicle I'm comparing.

Here's an example from a comparison between BEV and ICE Lariats. In this scenario, 85% of the time the Lightning was cheaper than the ICE. It all depends on variables, but I have to work at some really weird possibilities to make the ICE cost less (gas drops to <$1/gallon, etc). This scenario has a median of 18,000 miles/year driven for its runs (the miles driven per year is a variable in the simulation).

Ford F-150 Lightning Why isn’t the Lightning getting more of the gas F150 market? Screenshot 2024-12-30 at 22.10.26
 
Last edited:

B177y

Well-known member
First Name
Bill
Joined
Jul 16, 2024
Threads
3
Messages
128
Reaction score
156
Location
Olympic Peninsula WA
Website
www.ptcoffee.com
Vehicles
2024 Lightning Pro ER Max Tow
Occupation
Coffee Roasting
I wrote some software (well, spreadsheet functions) that model everything from the future cost of energy for the vehicle to the cost of maintenance to depreciation (first year and subsequent years), insurance, etc., etc., etc. I typically run 10,000 to 1 million simulations on each vehicle I'm comparing.

Here's an example from a comparison between BEV and ICE Lariats. In this scenario, 85% of the time the Lightning was cheaper than the ICE. It all depends on variables, but I have to work at some really weird possibilities to make the ICE cost less (gas drops to <$1/gallon, etc). This scenario has a median of 18,000 miles/year driven for its runs (the miles driven per year is a variable in the simulation).

Screenshot 2024-12-30 at 22.10.26.jpg
I'd love to hit that 20 year mark.
 

Sponsored

broncoaz

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 6, 2022
Threads
11
Messages
571
Reaction score
484
Location
Cape Cod, MA
Vehicles
2021 Bronco 2 door Badlands manual
I wrote some software (well, spreadsheet functions) that model everything from the future cost of energy for the vehicle to the cost of maintenance to depreciation (first year and subsequent years), insurance, etc., etc., etc. I typically run 10,000 to 1 million simulations on each vehicle I'm comparing.

Here's an example from a comparison between BEV and ICE Lariats. In this scenario, 85% of the time the Lightning was cheaper than the ICE. It all depends on variables, but I have to work at some really weird possibilities to make the ICE cost less (gas drops to <$1/gallon, etc). This scenario has a median of 18,000 miles/year driven for its runs (the miles driven per year is a variable in the simulation).

Screenshot 2024-12-30 at 22.10.26.jpg
Ford F-150 Lightning Why isn’t the Lightning getting more of the gas F150 market? IMG_7137
 

Kit2874

Well-known member
First Name
Kit
Joined
Dec 22, 2023
Threads
2
Messages
68
Reaction score
127
Location
Mississippi
Vehicles
F150 lightning
I got this STX loaner while my Lightning was getting fixed and with it 700 miles of range for $50k this is where I think our trucks need to get eventually to capture more of the 700k+ gas F150 sales. My original post on X / Twitter hit 75k+ views, so I went deeper with this video! 👇Why do you think is holding back the Lightning from capturing more of those huge gas sales?
Simple, people hate change.... Nothing more nothing less
 

broncoaz

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 6, 2022
Threads
11
Messages
571
Reaction score
484
Location
Cape Cod, MA
Vehicles
2021 Bronco 2 door Badlands manual
Simple, people hate change.... Nothing more nothing less
Climate change is a very polarizing issue in a country that is basically a 50/50 split between the two sides. Suggesting it’s the only reason why people aren’t buying a specific truck doesn’t make sense when people on both sides buy trucks. The 50% that “hate” climate change may avoid EV’s over the politics, I know plenty who feel that way. The other 50% of climate change “enthusiasts” should be snapping up the EV cars and trucks at a significant rate, but they aren’t because EV’s don’t work for all people in all situations and those people also have the same fears about the user experience. Even California only has 2.5% EV adoption.

I had a conversation with a friend of mine who is a big Tesla fan, loves his Model 3, lusts after other models. We were discussing the new Highlander Hybrid his brother had bought and how his brother should’ve gotten an EV instead. I was trying to explain to him that his brother’s wife was not the type to deal with an EV, she frequently takes trips out of state to see family and with two little kids onboard isn’t willing to stop and charge or do the route planning required by the EV. Her father drives an EV and had an issue with charging on a trip to see the kids out of state (before the Tesla network was open). I explained that they had gotten one of the best hybrids around that was basically foolproof, allowing them to put gas in and drive anywhere. The first time the EV caused distress they would freak out and want to get rid of it. He just didn’t get it and was saying they were stupid for buying anything other than a Tesla Y or X. In the conversation I was making the arguments for the hybrid and against the EV for people who aren’t ready for one. We need to keep in mind that what works for us doesn’t work for everyone.
 

Joe Dablock

Active member
First Name
Joseph
Joined
Dec 23, 2023
Threads
3
Messages
37
Reaction score
66
Location
Stewartstown Pa. 17363
Vehicles
2023 F150 Lightning, 2022 Mustang Mach E
Occupation
Retired
I agree that pretty much sums it up. But a day will come when the pendulum will stop and suddenly go the other way. And some day in the future, a person will say do you remember when cars used gasoline and you had to go to a convenience store to buy gas? How inconvenient!
 

Sponsored

Kit2874

Well-known member
First Name
Kit
Joined
Dec 22, 2023
Threads
2
Messages
68
Reaction score
127
Location
Mississippi
Vehicles
F150 lightning
Climate change is a very polarizing issue in a country that is basically a 50/50 split between the two sides. Suggesting it’s the only reason why people aren’t buying a specific truck doesn’t make sense when people on both sides buy trucks. The 50% that “hate” climate change may avoid EV’s over the politics, I know plenty who feel that way. The other 50% of climate change “enthusiasts” should be snapping up the EV cars and trucks at a significant rate, but they aren’t because EV’s don’t work for all people in all situations and those people also have the same fears about the user experience. Even California only has 2.5% EV adoption.

I had a conversation with a friend of mine who is a big Tesla fan, loves his Model 3, lusts after other models. We were discussing the new Highlander Hybrid his brother had bought and how his brother should’ve gotten an EV instead. I was trying to explain to him that his brother’s wife was not the type to deal with an EV, she frequently takes trips out of state to see family and with two little kids onboard isn’t willing to stop and charge or do the route planning required by the EV. Her father drives an EV and had an issue with charging on a trip to see the kids out of state (before the Tesla network was open). I explained that they had gotten one of the best hybrids around that was basically foolproof, allowing them to put gas in and drive anywhere. The first time the EV caused distress they would freak out and want to get rid of it. He just didn’t get it and was saying they were stupid for buying anything other than a Tesla Y or X. In the conversation I was making the arguments for the hybrid and against the EV for people who aren’t ready for one. We need to keep in mind that what works for us doesn’t work for everyone.
My comment had 100% absolute nothing to do about "climate change"

It had to do with change in general..
Holy 💩 my dude

IE

verb
1.
make (someone or something) different; alter or modify.
"both parties voted against proposals to change the law"
 

Firn

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 26, 2024
Threads
13
Messages
379
Reaction score
399
Location
USA
Vehicles
23 Pro ER
I wrote some software (well, spreadsheet functions) that model everything from the future cost of energy for the vehicle to the cost of maintenance to depreciation (first year and subsequent years), insurance, etc., etc., etc. I typically run 10,000 to 1 million simulations on each vehicle I'm comparing.

Here's an example from a comparison between BEV and ICE Lariats. In this scenario, 85% of the time the Lightning was cheaper than the ICE. It all depends on variables, but I have to work at some really weird possibilities to make the ICE cost less (gas drops to <$1/gallon, etc). This scenario has a median of 18,000 miles/year driven for its runs (the miles driven per year is a variable in the simulation).

Screenshot 2024-12-30 at 22.10.26.jpg
So one, can I get those functions!?!

But two, the initial cost is close to zero. We're you not including the initial purchase price?
 

SpaceEVDriver

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 9, 2022
Threads
17
Messages
337
Reaction score
567
Location
Arizona
Vehicles
2023 Lightning Lariat ER, 2022 Mustang Mach-E
So one, can I get those functions!?!
Yes. I need to figure out how to share the document. Mostly I need to figure out how to make it usable to people who aren't me...
How comfortable with Monte Carlo simulations are you?

But two, the initial cost is close to zero. We're you not including the initial purchase price?
I included depreciation. If you buy the vehicle and then sell it very early, you would get most of your money back. I believe this run had a mean depreciation of around 20% in the first year for the Lightning. The possible range was probably 15% to 30%. Reselling in the same year would return 70% to 85% of the purchase price. So, for a $67,500 purchase price with a $7500 tax credit ($60,000 out the door), a depreciation of 20% would be about $12,000. And a depreciation of around 15% would mean $9,000. Reselling in the first year would mean a total cost of ownership of around $12,000. The edges of these kinds of calculations are always funky, but they're also always a small number of datapoints, so they don't change the average much.

Justification for that value of depreciation:
This is the CarGurus used car index for the '22 and '23 Lightning.

Ford F-150 Lightning Why isn’t the Lightning getting more of the gas F150 market? Screenshot 2025-01-02 at 20.37.27
Sponsored

 
 





Top